ISO 9001 · 14001 · 22000 certified🚚 Pan-India dispatch from Vadodara
Co-polymer of MA/AA

Calcium Carbonate Scale & LSI Explained (with Cooling Tower Example)

Understand calcium carbonate scaling and how to calculate the Langelier Saturation Index (LSI) and Ryznar index, with a worked cooling tower example and how polymer choice depends on LSI.

By ZEEL PRODUCT Technical TeamPublished 2026-07-25Updated 2026-11-203 min read
Quick answer: LSI = pH − pHs, where pHs is the pH at which water is just saturated with calcium carbonate. A positive LSI means scale-forming water. Cooling towers often run at LSI 1.5–2.8, protected by polymers: PAA for LSI up to about 2, and MA/AA, HPMA or blends with PBTC for higher values.

What is calcium carbonate scale?

Calcium carbonate (calcite) is the most common deposit in cooling and boiler systems. Its solubility decreases as temperature rises (inverse solubility), so it forms first on the hottest surfaces: heat exchanger tubes, condensers and jackets.

The Langelier Saturation Index

LSI = pH − pHs, where pHs = (9.3 + A + B) − (C + D) and:

  • A = (log₁₀ TDS − 1) ÷ 10
  • B = −13.12 × log₁₀(T + 273) + 34.55 (T in °C)
  • C = log₁₀(Ca hardness as CaCO₃) − 0.4
  • D = log₁₀(M-alkalinity as CaCO₃)
LSITendency
< 0Undersaturated, may be corrosive
0 – 1Slight scaling
1 – 2Moderate scaling, polymer needed
> 2Severe scaling, strong blend needed

Worked example

Basin water at 4 cycles: TDS 1,600 mg/L, Ca hardness 400 mg/L as CaCO₃, M-alkalinity 320 mg/L, pH 8.6, and hottest skin temperature 50 °C.

A = (3.204 − 1)/10 = 0.22; B = −13.12 × log(323) + 34.55 = 1.62; C = 2.602 − 0.4 = 2.20; D = 2.505. pHs = 9.3 + 0.22 + 1.62 − 2.20 − 2.505 = 6.44. LSI = 8.6 − 6.44 = 2.16, so this water is strongly scaling.

Ryznar Stability Index

RSI = 2 × pHs − pH. In the example, RSI = 12.88 − 8.6 = 4.28. Values below 6 indicate scale, and below 5 heavy scale.

Choosing a polymer by LSI

  • LSI ≤ 1.8: PAA or a PAA + HEDP blend.
  • LSI 1.8–2.5: MA/AA + PBTC/HEDP.
  • LSI 2.5–3.0: MA/AA or HPMA + PBTC, with careful monitoring.
  • Phosphate or iron also present: add AA/AMPS or terpolymer.

Enter your LSI in the polymer selector for a quick recommendation.

Co-polymer of MA/AA 3D ball-and-stick molecular structure – ZEELCHEM™ 3000 water treatment polymer by ZEEL PRODUCT, VadodaraFEATURED PRODUCT

ZEELCHEM™ 3000 – Co-polymer of MA/AA

Maleic–acrylic copolymer for high-hardness, high-alkalinity water: calcium carbonate inhibition plus dispersion.

FAQ

What LSI is acceptable in a cooling tower?

With good polymer–phosphonate treatment, up to about 2.5, and up to about 3.0 with high-performance programs.

Which temperature should be used for LSI?

Use the hottest heat-transfer surface (skin) temperature, not the basin temperature.

Is negative LSI good?

No scale forms, but the water may be corrosive.

ZP
ZEEL PRODUCT Technical Team
Water treatment chemists at ZEEL PRODUCT, Vadodara. ISO 9001:2015 certified manufacturer of ZEELCHEM™ polymers.

More from ZEEL PRODUCT: zeelproduct.com · zeelproduct.net · ZEELCHEM™ range · online shop · zeelproductonline.co.in

Related articles

Need a polymer for your water system?

Share your water analysis and system details. Our technical team will recommend the right ZEELCHEM™ polymer and dosage, and send today's price with TDS, MSDS and COA.