Comparison
| Factor | MA/AA (3000) | HPMA (200) |
|---|---|---|
| Monomers | Maleic + acrylic | Maleic only |
| Mw | 3,000 – 5,000 | 400 – 800 |
| CaCO₃ at 50–80 °C | Excellent | Excellent |
| CaCO₃ at > 120 °C | Good | Excellent |
| Dispersion | Good | Weak |
| Calcium tolerance | High | High |
| Detergent use | Widely used | Limited |
| Cost per active | Medium | Higher |
Choose HPMA for
- MSF brine heaters and evaporators at high temperature. See HPMA in desalination.
- Boilers where thermal stability is the deciding factor.
- Waters where carbonate scale is the only problem.
Choose MA/AA for
- Alkaline cooling towers with some silt.
- Boilers needing sludge dispersion as well.
- Detergent formulations.
Blend option
For heavy-duty evaporators with suspended solids, a 2:1 HPMA:MA/AA blend combines both strengths. Compare all polymers on the products page, or view ZEELCHEM™ 3000 and ZEELCHEM™ 200.
FEATURED PRODUCTZEELCHEM™ 3000 – Co-polymer of MA/AA
Maleic–acrylic copolymer for high-hardness, high-alkalinity water: calcium carbonate inhibition plus dispersion.
FAQ
Is MA/AA cheaper than HPMA?
Generally yes, per kg of active polymer.
Can both be used together?
Yes. They are compatible and often blended.
Which is better for detergents?
MA/AA (as the sodium salt).
More from ZEEL PRODUCT: zeelproduct.com · zeelproduct.net · ZEELCHEM™ range · online shop · zeelproductonline.co.in

