ISO 9001 · 14001 · 22000 certified🚚 Pan-India dispatch from Vadodara
Polyacrylic Acid

Formulating Cooling Water Treatment with PAA and Phosphonates (HEDP, ATMP, PBTC)

How to build a cost-effective cooling water scale inhibitor by blending polyacrylic acid with HEDP, ATMP or PBTC: synergy, ratios, starter formulas and stability tips.

By ZEEL PRODUCT Technical TeamPublished 2026-07-21Updated 2026-11-203 min read
Quick answer: Blending polyacrylic acid with a phosphonate gives synergistic scale control: the phosphonate provides strong CaCO₃ threshold inhibition and the polymer adds crystal distortion and dispersion. A typical starter is 20–30 % HEDP or PBTC (as supplied) + 20–30 % ZEELCHEM™ 1000 + water, dosed at 30–80 mg/L.

Why blend polymer and phosphonate?

Phosphonates such as HEDP, ATMP and PBTC are very strong threshold inhibitors for calcium carbonate. On their own they disperse poorly, and at high calcium they can precipitate as calcium phosphonate. Polymers like PAA disperse well, distort crystals and keep calcium phosphonate in solution. Together they outperform either component at the same total dose. This synergy is why almost all commercial cooling water products are blends.

Choosing components

ComponentStrengthWatch out for
HEDPLow cost, strong CaCO₃ inhibitor, some corrosion inhibitionDegraded by high chlorine
ATMPGood CaCO₃ inhibition, good iron sequestrationLess chlorine stable
PBTCBest chlorine stability and calcium tolerance; low PHigher price
PAA (ZEELCHEM™ 1000)Dispersion, crystal distortion, cost-effectiveWeak on calcium phosphate
AA/AMPS (ZEELCHEM™ 3100)Phosphate, zinc and iron controlHigher cost per active

Phosphonates, azoles, zinc salts and biocides are available from the ZEELCHEM™ product range and zeelproduct.net.

Starter formulations (% w/w as supplied)

UseFormulaDose
General scale inhibitorHEDP 60 % – 25; ZEELCHEM™ 1000 – 25; water – 5040 – 80 mg/L
High-alkalinity, chlorinatedPBTC 50 % – 25; ZEELCHEM™ 3000 – 20; water – 5540 – 80 mg/L
Scale + corrosion (multi-metal)HEDP – 20; ZEELCHEM™ 1000 – 15; ZEELCHEM™ 3100 – 10; TTA – 2; water – 5360 – 100 mg/L

Important: These are starting points for laboratory evaluation, not finished products. Validate each blend with static jar tests (how to run one) and field monitoring.

Blending procedure and stability

  1. Charge water first, then add phosphonate with stirring.
  2. Add polymer slowly; the blend remains acidic and stable.
  3. Add azole last, pre-dissolved if it is a solid.
  4. Check pH, density and clarity, then store a retained sample for 30 days at 45 °C as a stability check.

Do not neutralise blends containing zinc without a stabilising polymer, because zinc hydroxide may precipitate. For zinc programs, see zinc stabilisation.

Polyacrylic Acid (PAA) 3D ball-and-stick molecular structure – ZEELCHEM™ 1000 water treatment polymer by ZEEL PRODUCT, VadodaraFEATURED PRODUCT

ZEELCHEM™ 1000 – Polyacrylic Acid

Low molecular weight polyacrylic acid for calcium carbonate scale inhibition and dispersion in cooling, boiler and RO water.

FAQ

What ratio of HEDP to PAA is best?

1:1 on an as-supplied basis is a common starting point; optimise by jar test for your water.

Can phosphonate–polymer blends be used in RO?

Yes, but RO antiscalants need different ratios and purity. See the AA/AMPS RO formulation guide.

Are these blends compatible with chlorine?

PBTC-based blends tolerate chlorine best. HEDP and ATMP slowly degrade above about 1 mg/L free chlorine.

ZP
ZEEL PRODUCT Technical Team
Water treatment chemists at ZEEL PRODUCT, Vadodara. ISO 9001:2015 certified manufacturer of ZEELCHEM™ polymers.

More from ZEEL PRODUCT: zeelproduct.com · zeelproduct.net · ZEELCHEM™ range · online shop · zeelproductonline.co.in

Related articles

Need a polymer for your water system?

Share your water analysis and system details. Our technical team will recommend the right ZEELCHEM™ polymer and dosage, and send today's price with TDS, MSDS and COA.